Out of 25 uses - my final results were:

12 Enchanter
7 Fairy
6 Ugly Witch
0 Shaman

So based on this and some other results I've seen from here and Preprod - the Rarity from Common to Rare seems to be:

Enchanter
Ugly Witch*
Fairy*
Shaman

*these two seem to be pretty close on which one is rarer, but based on the numbers I've seen - the Witch is a little more common than the Fairy which is why I put it first.

So my order of rarity would be:

Enchanter
Ugly Witch
Fairy
Shaman
(The same as Shorah)

However, for me, the Enchanter didn't take #1 spot until the 80th Magic Hat - the witch was the most common coat until then and even had a lead of around 20 above the Enchanter at one point.

Ok so after the piniatas what is the next event?

What do the new BMI coats look like? (I have skimmed the past few pages: have found nothing)

<-The icon that shows on a horse's page, sorry there does not seem to be a larger version of this

The Magic Hat allows you to personalize the coat of your horse.

There are 4 personalization options that are chosen randomly when you put the item on your horse:

Enchanter
Evil Witch
Fairy
Shaman

► Each coat is animated.
► When available in the Black Market, it costs 2 passes.
► If you get this item in your inventory you have 3 months to use it.
► You can give the item to horses from 18 months.
► It can be given to all horses except the Donkeys, Divine, Legendary and Wild horses.
► It gives your horse a +5 bonus in each skill.

What are the effects of each coat?

Enchanter: when a horse wears this coat, you do not use food when you feed it. (All of your horse's food becomes free.)

Evil Witch : when your Evil Witch horse participates tin a competition, it brings a penalty of 3 points on each skill to every other horse. It does not work on the Grand Prix.

Fairy: the Fairy horse gets a +5 bonus on each skill.

Shaman: the appearance of a Shaman horse changes every time he gets older. It can get:

► Its own coat
► One of the other Magic hat coats
► One of the Bewitched Pumpkin coats (except the ghost)
► One of the Seal of the Apocalypse coats (except Pestilentia)

The Shaman horse has the advantage of the coat it wears. If it gets its own coat it does not receive a special advantage.



The Magic Hat cannot be used in conjunction with another special coat. If you give your horse a Golden Apple and then a Magic Hat, your horse will lose their Golden Apple.

*Referring to winning it as a prize from the Halloween promotion. If you buy the item/give it to a horse - the horse will keep the coat forever!

Nothing. The Ponies showing in the Halloween images are just there as 'flavor' - because these trick-or-treaters are all from the Pony Club.

Trick or Treat Event!
We introduce a brand new contest where the objective is to give candy to children. If they are not happy with the candies they receive, they give you tricks!.

Obtain candies

There are 12 varieties of candies, with different degrees of rarity.

You can get candies :

► With your first connection of the day (15)
► When you groom your horses (4 max)
► When you win competitions (4 max)
► In the flash sales (one per day for each sort of sale)
► Making candies in your workshop
► By buying them with passes
► By buying pack in the Black Market (special operation, not available all the time)

Make candies in your workshop :

You can make certain candies in your workshop. The ingredients are different black market items. You can only use the ones you have in your inventory.
A candy production lasts 48 hours. So it is not possible to launch a production if there is less than 48 hours before the contest finishes.

Receiving the visit from children:

►You have 5 visits a day at the beginning of the contest. Each day the number of children who can visit you daily increase from 1. It means that if you connect on the game every day during the contest you will be able to receive more than 20 children a day.

►The children arrive all the day long. You have 36 hours to give a child candies, afterwards they will go away. There is a timer on each kid for you to know how long you can offer them candies.

►You can receive more visits of children by ringing a bell to call them. You can buy bell rings with passes. The children who arrive with the bell rings are more patient and stay until you give them candies (or the end of the contest). So there is no timer on those children.

Offer candies to the children

When a child is waiting for candies, you can see which ones will please him the most.

►Each child asks for 2 candies.

When you give candies to a kid, he gives you satisfaction feedback. You receive points corresponding to their satisfaction level: more he is satisfied, more points you will get. Those points will allow you to get gifts (see later).

If the kid is less than 50% satisfied, he will make you a trick.

Get gifts

With the points you receive from the children, you can get gifts and legendary tack to get Bucephale. Each gift has its price. You can see them on the contest page.

Tricks

When a kid is not happy, they make you a trick. We will not describe them to you; you can be surprised as you discover them. default smiley

Black Market

At certain moment during the contest you will be able to buy Halloween Packs in the Black Market.

Those packs contain:
► 2 rings bell
► 12 candies
► Common objective

Give candies to children to unblock chapters from the Bucephalus story!

Here are some screen shots of the event:


A kid asking for some candy.


A kid after being given the candy he asked for.


The prize list *please note, Bucephalus' Tack is shown in a different section


Points tracking bar and where Bucephalus' Tack is shown


Shot of a trick played by a child not happy with the Candy she received (This one was a Witch UFO that flew around the screen making it nearly impossible to click on anything and prevented one from scrolling down the page)

Day 1 - Pinata 1, 20 points = clicks worth 1, friend worth 2

9am - 1 normal click: 1/20
validate objective 1: 5/20
(validate objective 2)
1 friend click: 7/20 (make sure you get this before continuing with normal clicks)
9am - 13 normal clicks: 20/20 - Pinata breaks, 1 normal click left

*Start Pinata 2, 30 points*
9am - 1 normal click: 1/30
(validate objective 1)
1 friend click: 3/30
Validate objective 2: 13/30

Day 2 = clicks worth 1, friends worth 2

2 Friend clicks: 17/30 (make sure you get these before doing normal clicks)
9am - 13 normal clicks: 30/30 - Pinata breaks, 2 normal clicks left

*Start Pinata 3, 50 points*
(Validate objective 1 before clicking!)
9am - 2 normal clicks: 4/50
(validate objective 2 - clicks are now 12 hours apart)
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 20/50

Day 3 = clicks worth 1, friends worth 2

(Wait to use friend clicks!)
9am - 15 normal clicks: 35/50
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 50/50 - Pinata breaks

*start Pinata 4, 75 points*
validate objective 1: 20/75
(validate objective 2 - friend clicks now worth 3 points)
2 friend clicks: 26/75

Day 4 = clicks worth 1, friends worth 3

9am - 15 normal clicks: 41/75
2 friend clicks: 47/75
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 62/75

Day 5 = clicks worth 1, friends worth 3

(use friends clicks)
9am - 7 normal clicks: 75/75 - Pinata breaks, 8 normal clicks left

*start Pinata 5, 100 points*
(validate objective 1 - allows help from 3 friends)
(validate objective 2 - clicks are now worth 2 points each)
9am - 8 normal clicks: 16/100
1 friend click: 19/100
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 49/100

Day 6 = clicks worth 2 points, friends worth 3

9am - 15 normal clicks: 79/100
9pm - 11 normal clicks: 101/100 - Pinata breaks, 4 normal clicks left, 3 friend clicks left

*start pinata 6, 125 points*
Validate objective 1: 14/125
9pm - 4 normal clicks: 22/125
(validate objective 2 - Friend clicks now worth 4 points each)
3 Friend clicks: 34/125

Day 7 = clicks worth 2, friends worth 4

9am - 15 normal clicks: 64/125
3 friend clicks: 76/125
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 106/125

Day 8 = clicks worth 2, friends worth 4
9am - 10 normal clicks: 126/125 - Pinata breaks, 5 normal clicks left, 3 friend clicks left

*Start Pinata 7, 150 points*

(validate objective 1)
3 friend clicks: 15/150 *objective 1 makes the next 4 friend clicks worth 5 points*
9am - 5 normal clicks: 25/150
(validate objective 2 - clicks are now 8 hours apart)
5 pm - 15 normal clicks: 55/150
1am - 15 normal clicks: 85/150

Day 9 = clicks worth 2, Friends worth 4

9am - 15 normal clicks: 115/150
3 friend clicks: 128/150 *1 friend click worth 5, 2 worth 4*
5pm - 11 normal clicks: 150/150 - Pinata breaks, 4 normal click left

*Start pinata 8, 200 points*
(validate objective 1 - able to be helped by 4 friends)
(Validate objective 2 - Pinata now only needs 100 points to break)
5pm - 4 normal click: 8/100
1 friend click: 12/100
1am - 15 normal clicks: 42/100

Day 10 = clicks worth 2, friends worth 4

9am - 15 normal clicks: 72/100
4 friend click: 88/100
5pm - 6 normal clicks: 100/100 - Pinata breaks, 9 normal clicks left

*Start pinata 9, 250 points*
(Validate objective 1 - friend clicks now worth 5 points)
(Validate objective 2 - clicks are now worth 4 points each)
5pm – 9 normal clicks: 36/250
1am - 15 normal clicks: 96/250
Day 11 = clicks worth 4, friends worth 5

9am - 15 normal clicks: 156/250
2 Friend clicks: 166/250
5pm - 15 normal clicks: 226/250
1am - 6 normal clicks: 250/250 - Pinata breaks, 9 normal clicks left, 2 friends clicks left

*start pinata 10, 300 points*
(Validate objective 1 - next 5 normal clicks worth 5 points)
1am - 9 normal clicks: 41/300
2 Friend clicks: 51/300
validate objective 2: 71/300

Day 12 = clicks worth 4, friends worth 5
9am - 15 normal clicks: 131/300
4 friends clicks: 151/300
5pm - 15 normal clicks: 211/300
1am - 15 normal clicks: 271/300

Day 13 = clicks worth 4, friends worth 5
1 Friend click: 276/300
9am - 6 normal clicks: 300/300 - Pianta breaks, 9 normal clicks left, 3 friend clicks left

*start Pinata 11, 400 points*
(Validate objective 1 - clicks are now 6 hours apart)
Validate objective 2: 399/400
9am - 1 normal click: 403/400 - Pinata breaks, 8 normal click left, 3 friend clicks left

*Start pinata 12, 500 points*
(validate objective 1 - friend clicks now worth 6 points)
(validate objective 2 - normal clicks now worth 6 points)
9am - 8 normal click: 48/500
3 friend clicks: 66/500
3pm - 15 normal clicks: 156/500
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 246/500
3am - 15 normal clicks: 336/500

Day 14 = clicks worth 6, friends worth 6
9am - 15 normal clicks: 426/500
4 friend clicks: 450/500
3pm - 9 normal clicks: 504/500 - Pinata breaks, 6 normal clicks left

*Start pinata 13, 750 points*
Validate objective 1: 250/750
(validate objective 2 - able to be helped by 6 friends a day now)
2 friend clicks: 262/750
3pm – 6 normal clicks: 298/750
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 388/750
3am - 15 normal clicks: 478/750

Day 15 = clicks worth 6, friends worth 6

9am - 15 normal clicks: 568/750
6 friend clicks: 604/750
3pm - 15 normal clicks: 694/750
9pm - 10 normal clicks: 754/750 - Pinata breaks, 5 normal clicks left


*start Pinata 14, 1000 points*
(validate objective 1 - next click worth 100 points)
validate objective 2: 200/1000
(validate objective 3 - clicks are now worth 8 points each)
9pm – 5 normal clicks: 340/1000 (1 click worth 100, 5 worth 8)
3am - 15 normal clicks: 460/1000

Day 16 = clicks worth 8, friends worth 6

9am - 15 normal clicks: 580/1000
6 friend clicks: 616/1000
3pm - 15 normal clicks: 736/1000
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 856/1000
3am - 15 normal clicks: 976/1000

Day 17 = clicks worth 8, friends worth 6
9am - 3 normal clicks: 1000/1000 - Pinata breaks, 12 normal clicks left, 6 friend clicks left

*start Pinata 15, 1200 points*
validate objective 1: 300/1200 (do this before clicking!)
(validate objective 2 - friend clicks now worth 8)
9am - 12 normal clicks: 396/1200
6 friend clicks: 444/1200
(validate objective 3 - clicks are now 4 hours apart)
1pm - 15 normal clicks: 564/1200
5pm - 15 normal clicks: 684/1200
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 804/1200
1am - 15 normal clicks: 924/1200

Day 18 - clicks worth 8, friends worth 8
(wait to use friend clicks!)
5am - 15 normal clicks: 1044/1200
9am - 15 normal clicks: 1164/1200
1pm - 5 normal clicks: 1204/1200 - Pinata breaks, 10 normal clicks left, 6 friend clicks left

*start Pinata 16, 1500 points*
(validate objective 1 - next 6 friend clicks worth 20 points)
(validate objective 2)
(validate objective 3 - clicks are now worth 10 points)
6 friend clicks: 120/1500
1pm - 10 normal clicks: 220/1500
20 mace blows *gotten from objective 2*: 420/1500
5pm - 15 normal clicks: 570/1500
9pm - 15 normal clicks: 720/1500
1am - 15 normal clicks: 870/1500